Heaters Pool Repair Q&A

Heaters Hard Professional installation required 676 👍 0

Can Pool Heater and Pump Share Same Circuit? Safety Guide

Finally it's midnight and my pool heater tripped the breaker for the third time tonight — desperately need to know if wiring both heater and pump together is causing this mess. The pool store is pushing me to hire their electrician for thousands of dollars, but I'm handy with electrical work and want to do this myself if possible.

Before I start running wiring, I need to know if there are any safety issues with putting both the heater and pump on one circuit. They're both major electrical components so I want to make sure I'm not creating a fire hazard or code violation. Anyone have experience with DIY pool electrical work?…more

Read answer

Heaters Easy 30 minutes 421 👍 0

Do You Need Pool Heating in Orlando in April? Temperature Guide

Woke up this morning realizing our pool party is this weekend and I have no idea if April water temps in Orlando will freeze our guests out without heating. What are typical pool temperatures in April without a heater? Is it warm enough to swim comfortably or should I budget for heating equipment?…more

Read answer

Heaters Medium 2-4 hours 315 👍 0

Do You Need a Pool Heater Bypass? Installation Guide

Before I connect my new pool heater to the system, it's making this weird whistling sound when water flows through and now I'm wondering if a bypass valve would fix it. The manufacturer's documentation mentions bypass considerations, but I need clarity on whether this is mandatory or optional equipment.

Specifically, I'm concerned about maintaining proper flow rates through the heating unit and having the ability to isolate the heater during routine maintenance procedures. What are the technical requirements and operational benefits of incorporating a bypass valve system into the heater plumbing layout?…more

Read answer

Product Ranking 8 compared

Best Pool Heaters

4.4 (8,900 reviews)

Heaters Medium 2-4 hours for protective measures 241 👍 0

Can Pool Heaters Get Wet? Complete Weatherproofing Guide

Somewhere between last week's torrential downpour and watching my kids cannon-ball into the pool nonstop, I started panicking about whether our new heater is actually waterproof. We had it installed last month, but I'm concerned about whether it can handle direct rain, sprinkler overspray, and the humid conditions around our pool area.

Should I be covering it during storms? I want to make sure it stays safe and keeps working properly so the water temperature is always comfortable for the kids. What kind of protection does it actually need from water exposure?…more

Read answer

Heaters Medium varies by setup 227 👍 0

How Long Pool Heaters Take to Heat Up - Complete Guide

After years of relying on my old gas heater's predictable 24-hour heating schedule, this new heat pump is throwing me completely off track. They keep pushing expensive systems without giving me straight answers about actual heating performance. I need to know the real deal on how long different heater types actually take to warm up a pool.

Specifically, what's the realistic heating rate for gas heaters versus heat pumps? I keep hearing conflicting info and I'm trying to make an informed decision without getting upsold on features I don't need. Just want honest numbers on temperature rise per hour so I can figure out what works for my situation and budget.…more

Read answer

Heaters Medium 15 minutes reading 212 👍 0

Pool Heater Lifespan in Florida: How Long They Last

Turned on my pool heater this morning and noticed those same rust spots on my 8-year-old unit are definitely getting worse. With three young kids who love to swim year-round, having consistently warm water is important for their comfort and safety.

I've been looking at both gas heaters and electric heat pump options, but I'm concerned about how Florida's climate might affect their lifespan. The humidity here is intense, and we're close enough to the coast that salt air is definitely a factor. Should I expect to replace the heater more frequently than if we lived somewhere with milder weather? I want to budget appropriately and ensure we always have reliable heating for safe, comfortable swimming conditions.…more

Read answer

Heaters Medium 15 minutes reading 206 👍 0

How Long Do Pool Heaters Last? Complete Lifespan Guide

Standing next to my ancient pool heater that's been making weird noises, is it dangerous to keep running it another season with kids constantly using our 20,000-gallon inground pool?

From what I've researched, there seem to be pretty significant differences in how long each type lasts, but I'm getting conflicting information. Some sources say gas heaters burn out faster due to the combustion process, while others claim electric units fail sooner because of the heating elements. I'm also curious about heat pumps since they're more energy efficient, but I wonder if that translates to longer equipment life.

What should I realistically expect in terms of lifespan for each heater type? I'm willing to do proper maintenance and won't be running it constantly - probably just weekends and evenings during swimming season. Are there specific factors that significantly impact how long these units last?…more

Read answer

Heaters Medium 45 minutes 205 👍 0

How Solar Pool Heaters Work: Diagnosis & Troubleshooting

According to what I spotted this morning, my solar heater panels are just sitting there doing absolutely nothing while every "expert" keeps pushing gas systems instead. They keep pushing these pricey gas heaters and telling me solar is "complicated" - probably because there's less markup for them.

I want to understand the actual process of how solar pool heaters function before I make any decisions. Do they really just use the sun's energy somehow? I'm hoping to find a more cost-effective heating solution and maybe even explore some DIY options instead of getting ripped off again.…more

Read answer

Heaters Medium 15 minutes 202 👍 0

How Long Do Pool Heaters Last? Lifespan by Type & Maintenance

Found out after calling three different pool supply stores that each one gave me a totally different answer about how long my heater should last. I've been looking at gas, electric, and heat pump options, but I'm finding conflicting information about how long each type typically lasts.

My pool gets heavy use from April through October, and I'm pretty good about maintaining proper water chemistry (pH around 7.2-7.6, chlorine 1-3 ppm, alkalinity 80-120 ppm). I'm wondering if the heater type makes a significant difference in longevity, and whether factors like usage patterns and water balance really impact lifespan as much as some dealers claim.

What should I realistically expect for lifespan from gas vs electric vs heat pump heaters? I want to factor replacement costs into my decision since this is a long-term investment for our family.…more

Read answer

Heaters Easy 30 minutes 199 👍 0

Do I Need Pool Heating in Orlando in May? Temperature Guide

My neighbor insists pool heating is pointless in Orlando by May, the pool store says my 18,000-gallon inground absolutely needs it, and YouTube videos are giving me completely different advice.

I've been checking the water temperature with a digital thermometer, and it's been running around 78-80°F during the day in May, which feels okay but not quite warm enough for extended swimming sessions. My family prefers the water to feel really comfortable, more like 82-84°F if possible. We're early risers and often want to use the pool around 7 AM, plus evening swims are important for our routine.

Is pool heating typically necessary in Orlando during May, or do most people find the natural temperatures comfortable enough? I'm wondering if a heater would be worth the investment to extend our daily swimming hours and make the water more inviting for the whole family.…more

Read answer

Heaters Medium 20-40 hours 187 👍 0

Can I Install a Pool Heater Myself? DIY Installation Guide

Staring at my dead pool heater at 11 PM — need to figure out if I can install a replacement myself before the kids want to swim tomorrow. I keep reading mixed information about whether this is something I can tackle myself or if I need to hire a professional.

I'm particularly concerned about gas connections and electrical work - I don't want to mess something up that could put my family at risk. Are there certain types of pool heaters that are safer for DIY installation? I want to make sure whatever heating system we choose is properly installed so there are no safety hazards for the kids.…more

Read answer

Product Ranking 8 compared

Best Variable Speed Pool Pumps

4.5 (12,400 reviews)

Heaters Medium 2-4 hours for installation 182 👍 0

Can Salt Water Pools Be Heated? Complete Heating Guide

Halfway through summer my salt water pool heater works perfectly when it's below 80 degrees outside, but shuts down completely once temperatures hit the mid-80s. My current setup uses a standard salt water chlorine generator, and I'm concerned about potential interference or operational conflicts when adding a heating system.

Specifically, I need to understand which heating methods work effectively with salt water systems - whether gas, electric, heat pump, or solar options present any technical limitations. Are there material compatibility requirements I should consider, particularly regarding corrosion resistance with the salt water chemistry?

Looking for precise guidance on heating system selection and any modifications needed to ensure reliable operation with my existing salt water generator setup.…more

Read answer

Heaters Medium 15 minutes 181 👍 0

How Do Pool Heaters Work? Complete Guide to Pool Heating

Found myself staring at a pile of pool heating equipment with my tools spread out, ready to tackle this installation but totally lost on which system actually makes sense. Gas, electric, heat pump - they all claim to do the same thing but work differently somehow.

What's the actual difference between these heater types? How does each one actually heat the water? Want to understand the mechanics before dropping cash on one.…more

Read answer

Heaters Medium 15 minutes 177 👍 0

How Does a Pool Heater Work? Complete Guide 2024

Since this is my third pool heater confusion this season and I keep getting different explanations from everyone, I'm done pretending I understand how these systems actually work. I want to make an informed decision based on how each system actually operates to heat the water.

Specifically, I'm looking for detailed explanations of gas heaters, electric heaters, heat pumps, and solar heating systems. What are the fundamental differences in how each type transfers heat to the pool water? I need to understand the operational principles, not just basic pros and cons.…more

Read answer

Heaters Medium 2-3 hours research and planning 175 👍 0

Do You Need a Pool Heater? Complete Decision Guide 2024

Every winter since moving into this house with a pool, I'm stuck watching this expensive water feature sit completely useless for months due to freezing temperatures. I live somewhere that gets cold winters and even the summers aren't always warm enough to make the water comfortable. Right now I can only really use it for like 3-4 months when it's hot outside.

I keep going back and forth on whether to buy a heater or just accept that I have a very seasonal pool. What temperature should pool water actually be for comfortable swimming? And is it worth the investment if I want to use my pool more than just peak summer months?…more

Read answer

Loading more Q&A...

You've seen all 28 Q&A articles!