For informational purposes only. For complex pool issues, consult a qualified pool professional.
Tools & Supplies Needed
pool type identification
liner inspection tools
Find on Amazon:
Pool Liner Repair Kit ,
Pool Water Test Kit ,
Pool Liner Cleaner
Quick Answer
The answer depends entirely on your inground pool type. Concrete and fiberglass inground pools do not need liners - they have permanent, built-in surfaces. Only vinyl-lined inground pools require liners, which serve as the waterproof barrier and interior finish.
Understanding Inground Pool Types and Liner Requirements
Concrete/Gunite Pools - No Liner Needed
Concrete and gunite pools are the most common inground pool type and never use liners. Instead, they feature:
- Plaster finish: The traditional white or colored coating applied directly to concrete
- Aggregate finishes: Pebble, quartz, or glass bead surfaces for durability
- Tile finishes: Ceramic or stone tiles creating a permanent waterproof surface
These finishes are integral to the pool structure and typically last 10-20 years before needing resurfacing. The concrete shell itself provides the structural integrity and waterproofing.
Fiberglass Pools - Factory Finish Only
Fiberglass inground pools come with a permanent gelcoat finish applied during manufacturing. This smooth, non-porous surface:
- Resists algae growth naturally
- Never requires liner replacement
- Lasts 15-25 years before potential refinishing
- Cannot accommodate liners due to the molded shell design
Vinyl-Lined Inground Pools - Liner Required
Vinyl-lined inground pools are the only type that requires liners. These pools feature:
- Steel, aluminum, or polymer wall panels for structure
- Custom-fitted vinyl liner creating the waterproof barrier
- Liner replacement needed every 8-12 years
- Most affordable inground pool option initially
When Vinyl Pool Liners Need Replacement
If you have a vinyl-lined inground pool, watch for these replacement indicators:
Visible Damage Signs
- Tears or punctures: Even small holes can lead to water loss and structural damage
- Fading and bleaching: UV damage makes liners brittle and prone to cracking
- Wrinkles and stretching: Indicates liner material breakdown
- Staining: Permanent discoloration from metals or organic matter
Performance Issues
- Frequent water loss requiring constant refilling
- Difficulty maintaining proper water chemistry
- Rough texture indicating surface degradation
- Liner pulling away from pool walls or steps
Choosing the Right Vinyl Liner
Thickness Options
Vinyl liner thickness directly impacts durability and cost:
- 20-mil liners: Basic option lasting 5-8 years, most affordable
- 27-mil liners: Standard choice offering 8-12 year lifespan
- 30-mil liners: Premium option lasting 12-15 years with better puncture resistance
Pattern and Color Considerations
Beyond aesthetics, liner patterns affect maintenance and longevity:
- Darker patterns: Hide stains better but may fade faster
- Textured surfaces: Provide better grip but can harbor algae
- Solid colors: Show wear more readily but easier to clean
Maintenance Differences by Pool Type
Chemical Balance for Vinyl Liners
Vinyl-lined pools require careful chemical management to prevent liner damage:
- pH levels: Maintain 7.2-7.6 to prevent liner deterioration
- Calcium hardness: Keep at 150-250 ppm (lower than concrete pools)
- Free chlorine: Use FC/CYA chart but avoid shock levels above 10 ppm
- Total alkalinity: Maintain 80-120 ppm for pH stability
Important: Never add chemicals directly to the liner surface. Always dissolve in water first or add to the deep end with circulation running.
Cleaning Considerations
Different pool surfaces require specific cleaning approaches:
- Vinyl liners: Use soft brushes only, avoid abrasive cleaners
- Plaster surfaces: Can handle wire brushes for algae removal
- Fiberglass: Soft brushes only, similar to vinyl care
Cost Comparison and Long-Term Planning
Initial Investment
Understanding the cost implications helps with decision-making:
- Vinyl-lined pools: $35,000-$65,000 initially, plus $4,000-$8,000 every 8-12 years for liner replacement
- Concrete pools: $50,000-$100,000 initially, plus $5,000-$15,000 every 10-20 years for resurfacing
- Fiberglass pools: $45,000-$75,000 initially, minimal refinishing costs for decades
Lifecycle Maintenance
Factor in long-term maintenance when choosing pool types:
- Vinyl pools require the most frequent major maintenance
- Concrete pools offer the most customization but higher maintenance costs
- Fiberglass pools provide the lowest long-term maintenance requirements
Professional vs. DIY Considerations
Liner replacement requires precision and experience. Professional installation ensures:
- Proper measurement and custom fitting
- Correct water temperature for installation
- Proper wall preparation and cove installation
- Warranty coverage on materials and labor
DIY installation can save money but risks improper fit, premature failure, and potential structural damage to pool walls.
Pool Repair Question