Do I Need to Drain My Green Pool? Step-by-Step Solution
Green pool - do I really need to drain it or are stores upselling?
Read full question
Despite my husband insisting our algae-covered pool "looks like a swamp that needs to be drained," I'm wondering if the pool store's costly advice is actually necessary. The local pool store is telling me I need to drain the whole thing and start fresh, which sounds incredibly expensive and wasteful. They're also trying to sell me a bunch of expensive chemicals and treatments.\n\nI've been reading about DIY methods like the SLAM process but I'm not sure if that actually works or if I'm just wasting time. Has anyone successfully cleared a green pool without draining? I'm tired of throwing money at this problem and would love to know if there's a realistic way to fix this myself without the nuclear option of starting over.
Quick Answer
You typically don't need to drain a green pool. Most algae problems can be resolved using the SLAM (Shock Level And Maintain) method with proper chemical balancing and filtration.
When Draining IS Necessary
Before diving into the treatment process, let's identify the rare situations where draining might be your only option:
- Black or extremely dark water - If you can't see the bottom at the shallow end
- Structural damage visible - Cracks, staining, or deterioration that needs repair
- Contamination issues - Sewage backup, chemical spills, or hazardous materials
- Extremely high TDS - Over 3,000-4,000 ppm making chemical balancing impossible
- Multiple failed treatment attempts - After 2-3 weeks of proper SLAM with no improvement
Step-by-Step Green Pool Recovery Without Draining
Step 1: Test Your Water Chemistry
- Use a reliable test kit like the Taylor K-2006C to measure current levels
- Test for Free Chlorine (FC), pH, Total Alkalinity (TA), Cyanuric Acid (CYA), and Calcium Hardness (CH)
- Record all readings - you'll need baseline numbers to track progress
- If CYA is over 100 ppm, consider partial draining to dilute stabilizer levels
Step 2: Calculate Your Shock Level
- Determine your shock level based on CYA reading using the FC/CYA chart:
- CYA 30-40 ppm: Shock level 12-16 FC
- CYA 50 ppm: Shock level 20 FC
- CYA 60-70 ppm: Shock level 24-28 FC
- Calculate chlorine needed: 1 gallon of 12.5% liquid chlorine per 10,000 gallons raises FC by 1.3 ppm (adjust proportionally for different concentrations - check your product label)
Step 3: Balance pH and Total Alkalinity
- Lower pH to 7.2-7.4 using muriatic acid if above this range
- Don't worry about raising low pH during SLAM - chlorine addition will naturally raise it
- Adjust Total Alkalinity to 80-120 ppm for regular pools (60-80 for salt water generators)
- Add 1.5 lbs of sodium bicarbonate per 10,000 gallons to raise TA by 10 ppm
Step 4: Begin the SLAM Process
- Add enough liquid chlorine to reach your calculated shock level
- Run your pump and filter 24/7 throughout the entire process
- Brush all pool surfaces thoroughly - walls, steps, corners, and behind ladders
- Clean or backwash your filter when pressure rises 8-10 psi above clean pressure
- For sand filters, backwash daily during heavy algae treatment
Step 5: Maintain Shock Level
- Test FC levels every 2-4 hours during daylight
- Add more liquid chlorine to maintain your shock level - algae consumes chlorine rapidly
- Continue brushing twice daily to break up algae colonies
- Don't add algaecides - they can interfere with chlorine effectiveness and cause foaming
Step 6: Monitor Progress and Test for Completion
- Water should begin clearing within 24-48 hours
- Perform the Overnight Chlorine Loss Test (OCLT) once water is clear
- Test FC levels before bed and again first thing in the morning
- Loss should be 1 ppm or less overnight when algae is dead
- Complete three consecutive successful OCLTs before ending SLAM
Why Avoid Draining When Possible
Draining your pool creates several risks and expenses:
- Structural damage - Pools can crack or "pop" out of the ground without water weight
- Equipment damage - Pumps can run dry and burn out
- Higher costs - Refilling costs $200-600 depending on size and water rates
- Chemical restart - You'll need to rebalance entirely new water
- Time loss - Refilling and rebalancing takes 2-3 days minimum
Special Considerations
Sand Filter Users: Consider flocculant (floccing) if your sand filter can't clear fine particles. Add 4-6 oz of aluminum sulfate per 10,000 gallons (start with 4 oz and increase if needed), let settle 24 hours, then vacuum to waste.
Cartridge Filter Users: Have spare cartridges ready - you'll need to clean or replace them frequently during treatment. Rotate between sets while cleaning.
DE Filter Users: Expect to break down and clean your filter multiple times. Don't add new DE until the algae is completely dead.
Timeline Expectations
Most green pools clear within 3-7 days using proper SLAM technique. Factors affecting timeline include:
- Severity of algae bloom
- Filter type and condition
- Consistency in maintaining shock levels
- Thoroughness of brushing
- Starting chemical balance
Safety Warning: Always add chemicals to water, never water to chemicals. Wear safety goggles and gloves when handling pool chemicals. Ensure proper ventilation when using muriatic acid.
Tools & Supplies You'll Need
Still need help? Ask a Pool & Spa Expert
Get a personalized answer from PoolGuy810 — 30 years owning a pool and spa repair company. Describe your issue and get step-by-step help.
Related Pool Guides
Need More Help?
Try our free pool calculators and tools to help diagnose and fix your pool problems.
Browse Pool ToolsSLAM calculator, pH calculator, salt dosing & more